PBO Exposes Carney’s “Shadow Borrowing”: $765 Billion in Loans and Investments Hidden Beyond the $62.3-Billion Deficit

Teslim Teslim
5 Min Read

OTTAWA — Parliament’s budget watchdog is warning that the true scale of federal borrowing under Prime Minister Mark Carney’s fiscal plan is far larger than the headline deficit suggests, with hundreds of billions of dollars in loans, advances, and investments flowing through Crown corporations and arm’s-length entities that do not appear on the government’s balance sheet.

In a series of reports released Tuesday, Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan projected that total federal borrowing will reach **$764.7 billion over five years**—$476 billion more than the cumulative deficit of $289 billion . The gap reflects a surge in “non-budgetary transactions,” which include loans to Crown corporations like Export Development Canada, capital purchases of military equipment, and investments through the planned $25-billion Canada Strong Fund .

“The government promised to spend less to invest more. This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more,” Ryan said in a statement .

The Deficit Isn’t the Whole Story

The budget tabled Nov. 5 projects a deficit of $62.3 billion for the current fiscal year. But non-budgetary transactions add another $87.2 billion in borrowing requirements, bringing the total to $149.5 billion for the year alone . Over the forecast horizon, average annual borrowing requirements will be more than two and a half times the size of the average deficit .

Much of this borrowing does not count as spending because loans are treated as assets—money the government expects to be repaid. If a loan goes bad or a project flounders, only then would the loss show up in the deficit. But the money still must be borrowed, and interest must still be paid.

Ryan told MPs on the House of Commons finance committee that public debt charges are now the fastest-growing line item in the federal budget, projected to climb to **$85.5 billion by 2030-31** from $60.2 billion this year—more than the federal government spends on health transfers to provinces . On a per-capita basis, debt interest costs will rise from $1,440 this year to more than $2,000 by 2030-31 .

Government Defends Approach

Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne defended the strategy, telling the Senate’s national finance committee: “Confident countries invest. We’re one of the very few countries in the G7 who can afford to do that” . His spokesperson, John Fragos, said borrowing beyond the deficit is focused solely on generating future growth, pointing to the government’s fiscal anchors—a declining deficit-to-GDP ratio and a pledge to balance the operating budget—as proof of prudent management .

The PBO acknowledged that Ottawa’s spending plan “would be deemed sustainable” over the long term, with the debt-to-GDP ratio declining over the long term. But Ryan cautioned that the assessment does not incorporate federal pledges to increase defence spending to 5 per cent of GDP by 2035 .

Opposition and Experts Sound Alarm

Conservative finance critic Michael Chong said the PBO report confirms what critics have argued: “That the government is not on a fiscally sustainable track, that the debt is growing at ever-increasing rates, and that the interest on the national debt is now consuming much more than the federal government spends on public health care” .

The C.D. Howe Institute’s William Robson noted that the deficit and debt profiles “were usually fairly in line. Now they are spectacularly out of whack.” He warned that taxpayers should be concerned about what returns these government-directed investments will generate, pointing to a history of low returns from such initiatives .

Kevin Lynch, a former clerk of the Privy Council, wrote recently that “the deficit is no longer the relevant fiscal measure—it is borrowing requirements” . The PBO’s reports also raised questions about whether the government would meet its operating budget pledge under internationally accepted definitions of capital spending, and noted that neither fiscal anchor applies to the hundreds of billions in borrowing that doesn’t get counted in the deficit .

Share This Article
Leave a Comment