
TURIN, Italy — World No. 1 Alexander Zverev has been formally served with a new lawsuit from his former partner, Brenda Patea, who alleges the tennis star violated the terms of their out-of-court settlement by publicly claiming his “innocence has been proven” following a 2024 domestic abuse case .
Zverev’s Berlin-based lawyers, Christian Schertz and Anna Sophie Heuchemer, confirmed they were served with the lawsuit on Wednesday, in the middle of the ATP Finals. “Our client will defend himself against the lawsuit,” they said in a statement, arguing that if the statement was made as alleged, it constitutes “a permissible expression of opinion” protected by the German constitution .
The lawsuit, filed in September at Berlin Regional Court II, centres on an interview Zverev gave to French sports daily L’Équipe in June, the day after he won his first Grand Slam title at the French Open. According to the complaint, Zverev said: “It has been proven that the accusations were false” and “my innocence has been proven” .
Patea’s lawyer, Michael Scheele, told the Associated Press that Zverev’s claim “triggered a veritable storm of criticism against our client,” damaging her business as an influencer and violating her honour. “Quite apart from the fact that Zverev’s claim is false, he was not permitted to make any public statements whatsoever, in any form,” Scheele said. “Both Brenda Patea and Alexander Zverev had agreed to this in a settlement” .
The lawsuit seeks an injunction preventing Zverev from repeating the claim, with a proposed fine of up to €250,000 ($275,000) for each breach, along with damages for the impact on Patea .
The Legal Context
The dispute stems from a 2024 criminal case in which Zverev faced a charge of causing bodily harm to Patea during an argument in Berlin in May 2020. He has always denied any wrongdoing. In October 2023, he was issued a penalty order, which he contested, leading to a public trial in Berlin in June 2024. The proceedings were terminated after both parties agreed to an out-of-court settlement, with Zverev paying fines to the state and charitable organizations .
Crucially, the court stated that the decision was “not a verdict and it is not a decision about guilt or innocence.” A court spokesperson told The Athletic: “There is no court order establishing the defendant’s innocence, no final acquittal, or any other decision with corresponding content” .
Patea’s lawyers argue that Zverev’s public statement misrepresented this outcome. Zverev’s legal team, however, maintains that the criminal proceedings were discontinued without any finding of guilt, and that the presumption of innocence remains unaffected. They argue he was merely expressing his personal conviction that he had done everything to refute the allegations .
Zverev, who ascended to the No. 1 ranking this month and has won two Grand Slams this year, has not commented publicly on the lawsuit. His next match at the ATP Finals is on Thursday .
