Black Defence Lawyer Sues Durham Police for $7.1 Million, Alleging Racial Profiling in Violent Oshawa Courthouse Arrest

Teslim Teslim
4 Min Read

TORONTO — A Black criminal defence lawyer is suing Durham Regional Police for $7.1 million, alleging officers racially profiled her when they violently arrested her for trespassing inside the Oshawa courthouse—after she had already identified herself as a lawyer working late.

Sudine Riley, a petite five-foot lawyer who wears a headscarf, was participating in a Zoom meeting with the charity Level Justice in a courthouse interview room on Jan. 23 when an officer entered around 5:18 p.m. to tell her the building was closing, according to the statement of claim filed in court . Riley immediately identified herself as a lawyer and said she had just finished a late court appearance. The officer replied that he “did not care,” the claim alleges .

After Riley asked to speak to his supervisor, the officer left—but returned about three minutes later with several others. They allegedly kicked a chair aside, turned off the lights, and slammed her laptop shut while she was still in her meeting. The officers then grabbed Riley, slammed her face down into the desk, and forced her head down a second time when she tried to raise it, causing her face to bleed .

Riley alleges an officer pulled off her headscarf, while one or more officers applied body weight to her back and neck as she was pinned. Her skirt also rose during the struggle, “adding to her distress and humiliation,” the claim states . She was forcibly dragged from the room in handcuffs without being given a reason. When she asked why she was being arrested, an officer allegedly replied: “For not listening.” Another told her, “You don’t belong here,” while a third mocked her status as a defence lawyer .

The trespassing ticket she received was timestamped 5:10 p.m.—earlier than the time Riley alleges an officer first entered the interview room .

Riley is seeking $7.1 million in damages. The lawsuit names the Durham police services board, Chief Peter Moreira, and four unidentified officers as defendants. The officers’ actions “were imbued with bias relating to Ms. Riley’s race and/or skin colour,” the claim alleges. “The whole interaction was tainted by racial profiling” .

None of the allegations have been proven in court. Durham police said they cannot comment on matters before the courts.

The incident sparked widespread outcry from legal advocacy groups, including the Criminal Lawyers’ Association, the Canadian Association of Black Lawyers, and the BC Civil Liberties Association, all of whom called for an independent investigation . Durham police referred the criminal investigation to York Regional Police, which concluded in July there were “no reasonable grounds” to lay criminal charges against the officers . The matter has been referred to the Law Enforcement Complaints Agency to assess whether misconduct occurred .

Riley’s lawyer, Atrisha Lewis, said her client is “committed to pursuing all avenues to ensure accountability.” Riley has requested body-worn camera footage and other video of the incident but has not received any .

“Black lawyers, like all lawyers, should be able to work freely in courthouses in this province without being assaulted,” Lewis said .

Share This Article
Leave a Comment