Blue Jays’ Anthony Santander Faces Backlash After Reposting Islamophobic Content Following U.S. Midterms

Teslim Teslim
6 Min Read

Community organizations and advocates are speaking out after Toronto Blue Jays player Anthony Santander posted Islamophobic content on social media following the U.S. midterm elections.

In a series of Instagram stories that were later taken down, the right fielder reposted one reel featuring video of newly elected Michigan Senator Abdul El-Sayed with the caption, “America voted for Sharia last night,” and another that said, “Islam is not peaceful.” The reels were originally created by the American Truth Project account and a Gospel of Jesus Christ minister .

His stories were “hurtful” for many Muslim baseball fans, said Ahmad Al Qadi, a senior advisor at the National Council of Canadian Muslims (NCCM). “It puts them in a position where they’re now questioning whether they have a place in the sport, whether they have a place in Canada,” he told CBC Toronto. “It’s incredibly disappointing to see this kind of rhetoric being displayed by someone like Anthony Santander.”

Santander, 32, played 56 games during the Blue Jays’ 2025 run to the World Series but missed the entirety of this past season following shoulder surgery. He previously played eight seasons in Baltimore, including an All-Star year in 2024, and is now in the middle of a five-year, $92.5-million deal with Toronto. CBC Toronto has reached out to Santander and his agency for comment.

Blue Jays fan Hamzah Moin, who is Muslim, said he was in “a state of disbelief” and confusion when he first saw the reposts on his feed. “The Toronto community in and of itself is quite diverse,” he said. “You’d think the players would be on board embracing that kind of community.”

Moin said he would like Santander to apologize and to try to learn more about the community before playing for the Jays again. As for the team, he said he’s thankful they’ve responded so quickly, but hopes they’ll introduce some kind of inclusivity training. “There’s so many things in this Toronto community that he could experience and actually find quite a bit of joy [in] with his fellow Torontonians who are Muslim,” he added.

Moin said he watched the Blue Jays’ 2025 World Series run and was able to convert most of his family members, including his three young kids, into fans this year. He said he was actually able to run the bases with his kids—something that’s been a lifelong dream of his. “If he were to get healthy enough to rejoin the Blue Jays in the future and I see him walking on the field for his at bat, I don’t know what I would do,” Moin said. “I wouldn’t want to boo a Blue Jays player. But he’s subscribing to opinions that I’m not a big fan of.”

Al Qadi said online hate has become all too normalized, but it’s up to big corporations like Major League Baseball and the Blue Jays to stand up against Islamophobia. That’s why the NCCM has reached out and is discussing the incident, as well as next steps, with the organizations, he said.

In a statement to CBC Toronto Thursday, a spokesperson for the Blue Jays said the team has created an inclusive space where all fans feel welcome. “Baseball is for everyone,” the spokesperson said. “Individual comments do not represent our organization’s values and beliefs.”

Canada’s former special representative on combatting Islamophobia, Amira Elghawaby, said in a post on X that she expects more from the Blue Jays and Santander, whom she said is a role model and a public figure that many young sports fans look up to. “His reckless actions have impact, and we have seen anti-Muslim hate turn deadly in Canada,” she wrote. “Deleting his posts is not enough—Santander owes fans an apology, and the Blue Jays need to take a stronger stand against Islamophobic hate, and be transparent about how they plan to make this right.”

In a post to X Thursday, the Muslim Advisory Council of Canada called on the federal government to address Santander’s actions. “This issue should not be left solely to Muslim communities to condemn,” the non-profit organization wrote. “It is a matter of collective responsibility, and everyone, especially those in positions of leadership, must speak out and take a stand.”

The office for Canada’s Secretary of State for Sport, Adam van Koeverden, declined to comment.

Share This Article
Leave a Comment