Conservatives Brace for Tight Brantford—Brant South By-election as Independent Candidate Splits Vote

Teslim Teslim
3 Min Read

OTTAWA — After a year-and-a-half marked by defections, resignations and sagging poll numbers, Pierre Poilievre is staring down yet another challenge: Can the Conservatives hold onto a seat their party has held for the past 18 years?

With five weeks until the Dec. 7 byelection in Brantford—Brant South, Conservatives are bracing for a fight. Some MPs, speaking on background, anticipate the party could be dealt a loss amid concerns about its prospects across Ontario, a province key to any path toward forming government .

The race was triggered when Conservative MP Larry Brock resigned in September to return to his role as a Crown prosecutor . Poilievre then appointed Brantford’s outgoing mayor, Kevin Davis, as the Conservative candidate rather than holding a nomination contest—a decision that angered local party members .

That move spurred Dave Carrol, a local pastor and longtime Conservative who had Brock’s endorsement, to run as an independent. Carrol’s campaign is being aided by former Conservative MP Phil McColeman, who said the party’s grassroots “were ignored and democratic process thrown under the bus” . The party has revoked Carrol’s membership .

“We’ll have to wait and see,” Ontario MP Ben Lobb told the Star. “It doesn’t make it any easier with Dave Carrol running as an Independent” .

The controversy has drawn attention to Poilievre’s broader difficulties. The party has seen seven MPs leave its caucus since the 2025 election, including four who crossed the floor to the Liberals . Recent polling shows the Liberals leading the Conservatives 45.4 per cent to 28.9 per cent nationally .

Conservative strategist Dan Robertson called the situation “dismal,” suggesting Poilievre needs to demonstrate an ability to grow. “Hanging on to safe seats is not winning” . Retired political science professor Peter Woolstencroft was blunter about the Conservatives’ chances: “It’s very hard to see a Conservative victory. And if the Liberals don’t win this, I’ll be astonished” .

The Liberal candidate is Joy O’Donnell, chair of the Brantford-Brant chamber of commerce, who ran under Carney’s banner in 2025 . An aggregate projection from Vote-Scope gives the Liberals a 91 per cent chance of winning the byelection, projecting 49.5 per cent of the vote against 41 per cent for the Conservatives .

Poilievre has dismissed suggestions the byelections are a test of his leadership, framing them as an opportunity for Canadians to express dismay at the Liberals’ approach: “It’s an opportunity for hard-working Canadians who think it is unacceptable for Mark Carney to drive up their cost of gas, groceries and housing to vote for a party that will fight to save you money” .

Share This Article
Leave a Comment