Critics Warn Ontario’s Utility Reforms Are a “Stealth Privatization” of Toronto Hydro and Local Power Grids

Teslim Teslim
4 Min Read

TORONTO — Critics are warning that new provincial legislation governing Ontario’s electricity distribution sector amounts to a “stealth privatization” of municipally owned utilities like Toronto Hydro, opening the door to private investment and undermining local democratic control.

The Ford government’s reforms, introduced in late October and embedded within the omnibus Building Ontario Faster Act (Bill 140), impose sweeping new governance and financial requirements on the province’s 58 local distribution companies (LDCs). The changes, based on recommendations from the Panel for Utility Leadership and Service Excellence (PULSE), are framed by the government as necessary to prepare the grid for rising demand and an estimated $120-billion infrastructure gap over the next two decades .

However, the legislation limits municipalities to just one non-voting member on LDC boards, mandates “independent, skills-based” boards, and requires utilities to produce 10-year capital plans and undergo a “dividend stress test” . Critics argue these requirements will pressure smaller utilities into selling or merging with larger entities, potentially exposing them to private capital.

The Association of Municipalities of Ontario (AMO) has raised concerns that the governance changes would “significantly impact municipal voice on a wide variety of issues, even if a municipality retains majority ownership,” noting that the single municipal representative would be barred from discussions on topics like dividend policy .

Energy lawyer Thomas Timmins told The Globe and Mail that the new governance and financial requirements are aimed at encouraging consolidation among LDCs “without explicitly forcing them to do so,” adding that the changes “put a compliance burden on the smaller utilities” which could push municipal shareholders to conclude that maintaining independence is no longer viable .

The PULSE report itself acknowledged that some municipalities “must turn to alternative sources of capital such as pension funds and other institutional investors, or will need to merge with other utilities,” concluding that “access to external investment, particularly from Canadian institutional investors, is likely to be a critical determinant” of whether utilities can deliver needed infrastructure .

For Toronto Hydro—Canada’s largest municipal utility—the implications are particularly significant. Critics argue the reforms lay the groundwork for private ownership by making standalone municipal operation increasingly difficult and expensive. Similar language was used to describe the Ford government’s separate water legislation last year, which critics also labelled “stealth privatization” despite government assurances of public ownership .

The government has not specified shareholder composition requirements and says it is not requiring municipalities to become minority shareholders, leaving room for continued majority municipal ownership . But critics remain skeptical, pointing to the PULSE report’s explicit acknowledgment that private capital will be needed to meet the sector’s investment requirements—and that the governance changes will make it harder for municipalities to resist consolidation.

The legislation is expected to proceed swiftly through the legislature, with board composition requirements taking effect Jan. 1, 2027 .

Share This Article
Leave a Comment