
Mark Carney’s second budget makes an unmistakable wager: that massive incentives for business investment will catalyze the productivity growth Canada has been missing for years. It’s a bet worth making.
The centrepiece is the $36-billion “productivity mega-deduction,” which allows companies to immediately write off nearly all capital investments, bringing Canada’s marginal effective tax rate on new investment to 6.4 per cent—the lowest in the G7 . There’s also a new Canada growth incentive exempting entrepreneurs from capital gains taxes on up to $15 million if those funds are reinvested in a Canadian business.
Critics have zeroed in on the fact that oil and gas companies stand to receive roughly a third of the mega-deduction’s benefits, and that the measures are expensive at a time when the federal government is carrying $85.5 billion in annual debt charges by 2030-31. The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives called it “one of the most generous corporate tax breaks in Canadian history” and warned it would increase inequality while doing little for most workers .
But those criticisms miss the larger picture. Canada’s productivity crisis is not a recent development—it has been building for decades. The Bank of Canada warned in 2022 that productivity had reached emergency levels. Business investment per worker has been falling relative to the U.S. for years. Without a significant course correction, Canada’s standard of living will continue to erode, and the fiscal capacity to fund the social programs critics want to protect will shrink along with it.
The case for optimism rests on evidence from Canada’s own history. The 1990s fiscal consolidation was painful, but it was followed by a decade of strong growth that paid down the debt and funded major social investments. A well-designed investment incentive can work the same way—provided the projects it spurs are real and the jobs it creates are durable.
Sahir Khan of the University of Ottawa’s Institute of Fiscal Studies and Democracy put the risk plainly: “There are no jobs created by MOUs and frameworks. They’re done when the projects actually get financed, people get hired and we see economic activity” . That is the central question the budget must answer in the months ahead—not whether the tax incentives are generous enough, but whether they actually generate the investment they promise.
For now, Carney has chosen to act rather than wait. Given the alternative—drift, decline, and diminishing influence in a rapidly changing global economy—it’s a bet Canada cannot afford not to make.
