Johnny Depp’s $5M Scrooge Comeback: Critics Call ‘Ebenezer’ a “Slog,” But Theaters Bet on Star Power

Teslim Teslim
4 Min Read

Johnny Depp is attempting to re-enter Hollywood’s good graces with Ebenezer, a gothic take on Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol that casts him as the miserly Scrooge. It marks his first major studio role in nearly eight years, following the highly publicized defamation trial with ex-wife Amber Heard that derailed his A-list career .

The film, directed by Ti West (X trilogy), opens Friday with modest expectations: tracking suggests a roughly $20 million domestic debut and a similar figure from 63 international markets . Paramount kept the budget lean at a reported $38 million, with Depp earning $5 million—a fraction of his former studio paydays—plus performance bonuses . Marketing costs are estimated at $50 million .

The Reviews: A Mixed Bag

Critical reception has been decidedly split. The Associated Press delivered a scathing one-star review, calling it a “horror-tinged holiday slog” and lamenting that Depp’s Scrooge is a collection of “exaggerated expressions and theatrical flourishes” that tip into caricature . Slant Magazine dismissed it as “pure humbug,” arguing the film has “no gimmick to speak of” and exists solely as a redemption vehicle for its star . RTE noted that while Depp is “almost unrecognisable” beneath the prosthetics, his performance feels “decidedly conventional,” and the emotional core of Scrooge’s transformation rings hollow .

Not everyone was hostile. Variety rounded up early reactions that included praise for Depp as a “fiendish delight” and the film as a “wickedly fun holiday treat” with “refreshing new layers” . The New York Post was more measured, acknowledging Depp is “solid” as Scrooge once the character relaxes into the story’s emotional beats, but found the film around him “mediocre” and “forgettable” .

The Comeback Calculus

The central question—whether audiences are ready to welcome Depp back—remains genuinely uncertain. Theater owners have expressed cautious optimism. Regal CEO Eduardo Acuna said the Dickens character “seemed particularly suited to Depp,” praising the combination of a classic literary property and West’s distinctive style .

The marketing has leaned heavily into the meta-narrative of Depp’s return. The trailer opens with references to Jack Sparrow and Edward Scissorhands before Depp, as Scrooge, purrs, “It’s good to be back” . Crisis PR expert Evan Nierman called this a smart strategy: “When a company deals head-on with an issue perceived as controversial, you defang it” .

But not everyone is charmed. Author Maureen Ryan called making the comeback concept the center of the promotional push “tasteless and off-putting” . And Mary Anne Franks, a law professor who has written about the Depp-Heard case, noted that the broader cultural moment may favor his return regardless of the film’s merits: “Not only has he not suffered meaningful consequences, he’s been lauded, and he became a hero to certain people” .

For Paramount, the gamble is calculated. Ebenezer doesn’t need to be a blockbuster to justify its price tag, but its performance will serve as a bellwether for whether Hollywood’s doors remain open to Depp—and whether audiences are willing to separate the artist from the controversies that defined the past decade of his career .


Share This Article
Leave a Comment