Blue Jays Decline Myles Straw’s $8M Option, Eye Seiya Suzuki and Randy Arozarena as Outfield Upgrades

Teslim Teslim
3 Min Read

The Blue Jays aren’t necessarily breaking up with Myles Straw, but they have at least decided to start seeing other people.

The Jays had until 5 p.m. Monday to pick up the $8-million (U.S.) club option on Straw’s contract for the next season. They declined to do so, which means the 32-year-old outfielder is now a free agent .

Straw isn’t walking away empty-handed. He received a $1.75-million buyout, and the Jays aren’t on the hook for it—the Cleveland Guardians will pay it as part of the trade that sent Straw to Toronto prior to the 2025 season . The move was announced alongside a flurry of roster moves as free agency officially opened Monday .

The decision was hardly a surprise. Straw, a glove-first reserve, regressed at the plate in 2026, slashing .241/.304/.342 with three home runs and 26 RBIs in 147 games . His OPS dropped from .680 in 2025 to .646, and his sprint speed and defensive metrics also declined . With Brett Bateman emerging as a center-field option, the Jays determined the $8-million price tag was better spent elsewhere .

Toronto remains in the market for someone with Straw’s skill set—ideally a right-handed platoon partner for Bateman who can play all three outfield spots—but the priority is adding more offence . The Jays finished last in runs scored this past season and were 19th in OPS from their outfielders .

According to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic, Toronto is expected to be “active” in the outfield market, with Seiya Suzuki and Randy Arozarena identified as logical fits . Suzuki, a Gold Glove finalist, slashed .270/.368/.473 with 26 home runs and 86 RBIs for the Cubs and is projected for a four-year, $90-million deal . Arozarena is coming off a career-best season in Seattle, hitting .281 with 26 homers, 79 RBIs, and an .865 OPS while earning his second consecutive All-Star nod .

For the bench, Tyrone Taylor has been identified as the most logical replacement for Straw’s role—a versatile defender who produced a .921 OPS against lefties in 2026 and could be had on a one-year deal in the $5-million to $8-million range .

Whether Straw returns at a lower price remains possible. He spoke fondly of Toronto at season’s end: “Whatever the team decides to do, I love it here and I hope I’m back. I’d love to be back” . But with free agency barely underway and a likely lockout looming on Dec. 2, lower-tier players like Straw may have to wait for the market to develop .


Share This Article
Leave a Comment