
Ontario Premier Doug Ford is pushing forward with a $3-billion plan to build up to three new casinos in Niagara Falls, despite deep skepticism from within his own government and warnings that the proposal could cannibalize existing gambling revenues and leave taxpayers on the hook.
The plan, part of Ford’s broader “Destination Niagara” strategy, has been described by multiple Progressive Conservative insiders as a personal fixation. “It’s his baby. He really wants to do it,” one senior Tory source told the Star . Another source, with direct knowledge of internal discussions, likened the situation to Ford’s ill-fated purchase of a $28.9-million private jet earlier this year: “Everyone knows it’s a dumb idea but no one wants to tell him until after everything goes south” .
The Flawed Economics
Critics inside and outside government point to a fundamental problem: adding more brick-and-mortar casinos in a market where existing facilities are already struggling. Casino Niagara and Fallsview Casino, operated by Mohegan Tribal Gaming Authority, have reported earnings declines in recent fiscal quarters as online gambling surges . The province’s own online gaming business generated $882 million directly for OLG in 2024-25, up 18 per cent, while traditional casino revenues lag .
“Why drive to a casino when you can blow your money at home on sports betting or online casinos?” the National Post’s Randall Denley asked in a column criticizing the plan . The government has also agreed to compensate Mohegan for any revenue losses caused by new competitors—a deal that one source described as leaving the existing operator “quite pleased” while exposing the province to financial risk .
The Municipal Pushback
Niagara Falls mayor-elect Lori Lococo, who defeated a 16-year incumbent in October on a platform that included concerns about casino expansion, has formally requested that the province hold public consultations before proceeding. She noted that when the first casino opened in 1996, there was a local referendum—and residents now want their voices heard again .
“The information provided should explain the anticipated benefits, potential community impacts and proposed safeguards,” Lococo wrote in a Nov. 3 letter to Tourism Minister Zee Hamid . She has also called for the release of a provincial study that found online problem gambling rates were significantly higher than expected—a study the government has kept confidential .
The Industry Skepticism
Gaming consultants doubt the plan will attract serious bidders. The government is requiring a minimum $1.5-billion investment and a $100-million entrance fee from operators, with submissions due Dec. 3—a timeline one consultant called unusually short . Brian Carr, a U.S.-based gaming consultant and former Caesars executive, said he “would be very surprised if even two companies were seriously thinking about this” . Another expert noted that millions of potential gamblers in nearby New York and Pennsylvania don’t have valid passports to cross the border .
Ford, for his part, remains undeterred. “In Niagara Falls, you just can’t sit back, you know, it’s not good,” he said earlier this month. “It’s just not a great destination. We want to make it the greatest destination in the world and the status quo is unacceptable” .
