
A senior Honda executive is warning that a planned U.S. tariff hike on Canadian steel and autos would badly hurt the North American auto industry. Jennifer Thomas, senior vice-president of corporate affairs at American Honda Motor Co., told an industry conference in Detroit on Tuesday that doubling the tariffs on Jan. 1, 2027 would be “catastrophic.” The increase was announced by President Donald Trump after the countries’ trade talks collapsed in August. It would raise the 25 percent tariff on Canadian vehicles to 50 percent. Canadian steel already faces U.S. duties of up to 50 percent. odt
Thomas said she is “cautiously optimistic” the increase can be avoided. Her comments came a day after Reuters reported, citing two U.S. and four Canadian sources, that the two governments are working on a deal to ease the Section 232 duties. U.S. sources told Reuters the administration wants more concessions from Ottawa. On Wednesday, Prime Minister Mark Carney said Canada is not yet in a position to reach an agreement. Thomas also stressed that the North American trade agreement is vital to U.S. competitiveness, and she said it needs to stay in place for the American industry to succeed.
The pact adds a complication that bilateral deals don’t have: rules of origin. A vehicle needs 75 percent regional content to qualify for preferential treatment. Since May, U.S. negotiators have pressed Mexico to raise that threshold to 82 percent, with half of each vehicle’s value produced in the United States, Reuters reported. As tabled, the proposal did not count Canadian parts toward the totals. It is not yet clear whether a similar demand will be put to Canada.
The framework the countries reportedly reached in Washington on Aug. 18, before talks broke down, shows what relief could look like. The U.S. tariff on Canadian autos would have fallen to 15 percent from 25 percent, and steel and aluminum duties would have been halved to 25 percent, with most Canadian steel covered by quotas, Bloomberg reported. Hub co-founders Rudyard Griffiths and Sean Speer estimated the effective auto tariff could have been closer to 7 percent for some models after credits for U.S. content.
How much damage the duties do depends on how tightly production is linked across the border. Parts and vehicles cross several times before sale, and a lasting change could decide where the next generation of plants is built. Alicia Planincic of the Business Council of Alberta, using U.S. Census Bureau data, estimates that more than 70 percent of U.S. transportation and equipment imports from Canada and Mexico are bought by related American companies, so much of any tariff lands on U.S. firms trading with their own affiliates.
The wider economy is less exposed. New 50 percent U.S. tariffs on roughly 5 percent of Canadian exports took effect Aug. 22, and RBC Economics estimated that more than 80 percent of Canadian exports would still cross the border duty-free. It also estimated Canada’s average effective tariff rate would rise to around 6 percent from about 3 percent. Still, a permanent gap of even a few points would weigh on an auto industry worth 0.7 percent of GDP. Neither government has announced terms, and without a deal the 50 percent rate takes effect Jan. 1, 2027.

