Toronto Judge Calls Lifting Ban “Unfair” to Attacker Before Handing Down “Very Low” Sentence in Sexual Assault Case

Teslim Teslim
3 Min Read

TORONTO — A Toronto judge has acknowledged imposing a “very low” sentence on a man who violently sexually assaulted his ex-girlfriend, and expressed hesitation over a request to lift the publication ban on the attacker’s name—because it felt “very unfair” to him.

Superior Court Justice Gillian Roberts sentenced Frederick Moore to three-and-a-half years for aggravated sexual assault, minus about eight months’ credit for time served, far below the eight years the Crown had sought. Moore was promptly released on bail pending appeal .

The victim, Susan Gilbreath, had asked to have the publication ban lifted so she could speak openly about the March 2023 attack, in which Moore ripped off her pants, tried to penetrate her with his fingers, shoved a tampon in her mouth, and chased her into an elevator where he banged her head against the wall. The ban had also shielded Moore’s identity, which Gilbreath said allowed him to “hide from what he had done” .

When Gilbreath made the request, Roberts hesitated. The judge noted that Moore had candidly offered personal information during sentencing—including about his own childhood abuse and alcoholism—with the understanding that his name would be protected. “I’m concerned there’s a basic unfairness in lifting the ban,” Roberts said. “I feel like I’m ripping the carpet out from under him in a way that feels very unfair to me” .

Crown attorney Brad Ververs repeatedly pointed to what the law says, as Gilbreath watched from the public gallery, stunned. She described her reaction to the Star: “It was me, the victim, who kept on having to deal with (Moore’s) power and control after the fact. Who are we protecting here? Are we protecting the victim? Or are we protecting the perpetrator?”

Roberts called a recess, then returned stating she had read the Criminal Code section on publication bans in full and ordered the ban lifted .

In handing down the sentence, Roberts acknowledged the disparity. “I am mindful that this is a very low sentence given the seriousness of the offence and the effect on the victim,” she said, but concluded it was appropriate “in the unique circumstances of this case”—primarily because Moore admitted to the facts, avoiding a trial .

Gilbreath, 50, said she felt “numb—completely numb” after the sentencing. “I feel that because I survived, I’m more or less being punished,” she told the Star. “I really feel that if he killed me that day, that maybe the outcome would be different” .


Share This Article
Leave a Comment